Book Reviews

The Notebook Trilogy

Ágota Kristóf

★★★★☆

Thanks to NetGalley and Grove Atlantic/Grove Press for the e-ARC.

The Notebook Trilogy follows twin boys who are sent to live with their grandmother in a border town during a war. The twins invent exercises to toughen themselves physically and emotionally, recording their experiences in a notebook. What follows is disturbing and unpredictable, and the strangeness escalates over the course of the three books.

I really enjoyed Kristóf's writing style. She makes every word count. Her short, simple sentences and matter-of-fact delivery make the worst events even more impactful. Her delivery also enhanced the unexpected dark humor and irony.

The characters are excellent. The twins, of course, are the main highlight. They are fascinating, especially their odd relationship with morality and how they respond to the people around them. I appreciated that even the smaller figures, like the priest and the paper shop owner, feel like real people and not just plot devices.

The story goes deeper than just describing what it's like to survive a war. It explores what suffering, political upheaval, separation and trauma do to people. It looks at how those things affect how people treat each other, how they see themselves, and how they remember their own lives.

I loved the first two books. Then, the third goes experimental, rewriting and reframing what came before, and I was less engaged because I found it a bit repetitive and confusing. But I think that disorientation is a deliberate part of Kristóf's exploration of memory, identity and whether truth can ever be pinned down, so the third book's willingness to unsettle everything you thought you knew makes sense. It just worked less well for me than the first two.

While I found some parts of The Notebook Trilogy to be graphic and disturbing, I'm glad I read it. Even though it's a hard read at times because of the subject and because of the structural shifts, it kept me reading because I genuinely had no idea what was going to happen next. I'd recommend this book to readers who enjoy strange, disturbing, and darkly funny books that sometimes leave you scratching your head.

Content warnings: war, death, child abandonment, child abuse, child sexual exploitation, pedophilia, incest, rape, sexual violence, bestiality, physical abuse, torture, suicide, murder, and alcoholism.

This book on Goodreads